Frequently Asked Questions...
Altruism in people?
True altruism in animals has been overwhelmingly discredited, the majority of perceived cases being attributed to either kin selection or recipricl altruism. Can seemingly altruistic behavior in humans be described as such also? Western society has entire career fields based on altruism, e.g. life guards, police officers, fire fighters, military. How is this paradox reconciled?
Good answers so far. Any idea how we could quanitfy the costs involved with Hamilton's rule?
Also, what about the fact that there are less risky jobs out there that pay the same or more?
What about random acts of heroism resulting in death, for example the New York subway guy who recently risked his life for a stranger.
Answer:
I think that you have to look in to the benefits that these people would receieve from their actions. There is no reason to think that Humans are any different from other animals.
Altruism is always going to come down to either Kin Selection or Reciprocal Altruism. In otherwords, there is always going to be a benefit to the individual.
For instance, all of those that you have listed in your questions are going to be rewarded for their efforts. It just happens that the field they work in (apart from military) has something to do with social service. They will all get paid, and provide for themselves and family off the back of this work.
Even volunteers will have a benefit from the work they do - even if it is just social kudos. It is just a matter of digging deep enough into the individual's motive. (In fact, it could be argued that someone is doing somehting altruistic to make them feel good abouth themselves, and therefore could be somewhat motivated by selfishness)
 3 ORIGINAL 8 X 10 PHOTOS OF U.S. MILITARY FIGHTER JETS US $7.00 
|
 F/A-18E SUPER HORNET FIGHTER USN MILITARY MODEL PLANE COLLECTOR'S GIFT ITEM US $129.95
|
 Vintage F-5E Northrop Aircraft Desk Model Fighter Jet Plane Air Force Military US $114.99
|
 Aviation Art Sketch USAF Fighter Aircraft Military FM US $9.95
|
 Aviation Art Sketch USAF Fighter Aircraft Military FM82 US $9.95
|
 1942 Ad WWII Vultee Aircraft Paratrooper Military Aviation Fighter Airplanes US $46.95
|
 ORIGINAL MILITARY AIRCRAFT/AVIATION/AEROPLANE COLOURSLIDE OF A F-16 FIGHTER. US $.08
|
 1942 Ad Allison Military Aircraft Engines World War II Fighter Bomber Jet Tigers US $47.95
|
 1944 Ad Good Year Military Aircraft World War II Fighter Bomber Jet Airplane US $46.95
|
 1942 Ad Goodyear Military Aircraft World War II Fighter Planes Bomber Sky Clouds US $46.95
|
 US MILITARY VIETNAM KOLLSMAN MC-2 COUNTER POINTER FIGHTER JET COCKPIT ALTIMETER US $9.99
|
 WWII D520 Fighter French Military display airplane US $13.97
|
 WWII BF109 fighter airplane Military display aircraft US $13.97
|
 USAF F16 Falcon Military Tactical Jet Fighter aircraft not a kit 8-1/2" long US $26.95
|
 EF 2000 German Air Force Jet Fighter Military aircraft 6" wing span 8" long 1:72 US $28.95
|
 F/A-18C HORNET BLUE ANGELS FIGHTER MILITARY QUALITY DESKTOP AIRCRAFT DISPLAY US $79.95
|
 Portugal F84 Air Force Jet Fighter Military aircraft 6-½" inch wing span US $28.95
|
 Military World War 2 Model Fighter Plane RB2.22 US $5.00
|
 F16 FIGHTER Airplane Aircraft Aviation Collectable Military Embroidered Patch US $6.00
|
 F15 FIGHTER Airplane Aircraft Aviation Collectable Military Embroidered Patch US $6.00
|
 Military Grn Aircraft Fighter Bomber Jet Hat Lapel Pin US $5.99
|
 US Military F14 Tomcat Fighter Bomber Aircraft Hat Lapel Pin Army Navy Air Force US $5.99
|
 P-40B TOMAHAWK WW2 FIGHTER MILITARY WOOD MODEL AIRCRAFT PERFECT GIFT DISPLAY US $209.95
|
 WWII Orig. Cockpit Gyro British Spitfire Supermarine Fighter Military Aviation US $25.00
|
 Original 1968 vietnam era air force 35mm slide jet fighter plane military US $4.99
|
 Original 1968 vietnam era air force 35mm slide jet fighters plane military US $4.99
|
 MILITARY AIRCRAFT/AEROPLANE/PHOTOGRAPH/PICTURE/PRINT OF A USAF F-16 FIGHTER. US $.87
|
 MILITARY AIRCRAFT/AEROPLANE/PHOTOGRAPH/PICTURE/PRINT OF A FIGHTER JET UNDERNEATH US $.87
|
 US military fighter airplane WWII US $15.99
|
 Vtg USAF Military Aircraft Plane Photo 334th Squadron Fighter Interceptor WWII US $9.99
|
 MAHOGANY WOOD COLLECTIBLE MILITARY F-4 FIGHTER JET MODEL AIRCRAFT AIRPLANE US $59.99
|
 Military Mig-15/J-5 Fighter Cockpit Gyro Horizon Instrument Indicator BDP-3 US $99.99
|
 RETIRED MILITARY AIRCRAFT MIG FIGHTER COCKPIT INSTRUMENT INDICATOR US $29.99
|
 Vintage Military Mig-15 Fighter Cockpit Radio Heading Indicator Instrument US $39.99
|
 1940 Ad Brewster Dive Bomber Fighter Military Airplane Wartime Air Force US $43.95
|
 1940 Ad Brewster Fighter Dive Bomber Military Airplanes Wartime Air Force US $44.95
|
 1943 Ad Cadillac General Motor Logo Fighter Plane WWII Military Aircraft Vickery US $44.95
|
 1942 Ad Bell Aircraft Military WWII Fighter Jets Bomber Planes Aira cobras US $45.95
|
 Vintage A-6 Intruder fighter Military Airplane Pin US $8.95
|
 Republic P-47D Thunderbolt Razorback U S Army Air Forces fighter military plane US $6.99
|
 1943 Ad Oldsmobile General Motors Fire-Power Fighter Plane Military Aircraft WW2 US $38.95
|
 MILITARY DVD BOX SET - ULTIMATE AEROPLANE FIGHTERS US $39.74
|
 1943 Ad McDonnell Military Aircraft Plastic Fighter Pilot WWII War Heier US $42.95
|
 F/A-18C HORNET BLUE ANGELS FIGHTER MILITARY MODEL PLANE US $129.95
|
 F/A-18E SUPER HORNET FIGHTER USN MILITARY MODEL PLANE COLLECTOR'S GIFT ITEM US $129.95
|
 1942 Ad Boeing Military Aircraft World War II Fighter Jet Gunner Flying Fortress US $38.95
|
 1943 Ad Borg Warner Pesco Fighter Pilot Military Aircraft WWII War Production US $41.95
|
 Vintage F-5 Freedom Fighter Military Aircraft Pin US $9.95
|
 Vintage F-5 Freedom Fighter USAF Military Aircraft Pin US $12.95
|
 Vintage Blue Angels F-6F Hellcat Military Fighter Pin US $12.95
|
 MILITARY AIR FORCE JETS POSTER-14 FIGHTER AIRPLANES ON ONE POSTER! STEALTH, F-18 US $9.99
|
 US Airpower Military Jet Aircraft Fighter Sticker LOT10 US $8.00
|
 FB111 Fighter Airplane Aircraft Aviation Collectable Military Embroidered Patch US $6.00
|
 Vintage illustrated image of Pilot in Military Jet Fighter ROHM & HAAS 1953 Ad US $3.27
|
 1988-35mm ORIGINAL SLIDE GUN FIGHTER 2 COL. ROY/RAY MILITARY PROP AIRCRAFT US $5.49
|
 Airplane-A7D CORSAIR II Fighter Military Plane Postcard Missiles Aircraft US $1.98
|
 Nice Silver/Pewter tone Military Fighter aircraft Military Style Belt buckle US $9.99
|
 F-14 US NAVY FIGHTER JET MILITARY JACKET PATCH US $7.84
|
 McDonnell Douglas F-15 Fighter Military Jet US $119.00
|
 1953 Military Jet Fighter Bomb Target Wind Scale NOS US $99.95
|
 F-117 A STEALTH FIGHTER BOMBER PENCIL SHARPENER military aircraft desk shelf jet US $9.99
|
 Northrop F-5 Jet Fighter Bomber Military Aviation USAF US $29.40
|
 Northrop T38 trainer Jet Fighter Military Aviation USAF US $25.20
|
 BELT BUCKLE STEALTH FIGHTER F-117A MILITARY 1989 COLLEC US $14.95
|
 F-117A Stealth Fighter Military Aircraft Illustrated Paperback by Andy Sun US $6.95
|
 *F-22 Raptor Military Jet Fighter* 3D Laser Etched Crystal K1017s US $9.99
|
 Scarce 1979 Aces High General Dynamics Book - Military Fighter Pilots WWI WWII + US $39.95
|
 SPITFIRE FIGHTER PROP PLANE VINTAGE MILITARY AVIATION PHOTO PRINT US $31.49
|
 MESSERSCHMITT ME-110 GERMAN FIGHTER PLANE WWII MILITARY AVIATION PHOTO PRINT US $31.49
|
 WWII STORMVIK FIGHTER PLANE VINTAGE MILITARY AVIATION PHOTO PRINT US $27.99
|
 US NAVY F-14 FIGHTER JET 3.5" MILITARY JACKET ARM PATCH US $7.84
|
 APACHE FIGHTER HELICOPTERS U.S.MILITARY ARMY PHOTO VETERANS PILOTS HIGH TECH US $17.95
|
 3 WWII FIGHTER AIRPLANES P-40/P-51/P-38 MILITARY CHRISTMAS BALL ORNAMENTS -BOXED US $24.98
|
 CLASSIC AIRCRAFT~AVAITION HISTORY~MILITARY~FLIGHT~HC/DJ~BOMBERS~FIGHTERS~JOHNSON US $15.00
|
 Nice Old Lapel Pin Tac-back AFRES Jet Airplane Fighter Military A-10 Warthog or US $7.99
|
 Military Camo Aircraft Airplane Fighter Hat Lapel Pin US $7.99
|
Fighter Military
Military Footy - fighter jets low flying
Here are a list of other products on Aviation World, come check these out:
